SBWQFT-Logo-200SBWQFT-sticky-200SBWQFT-sticky-200SBWQFT-sticky-200
  • Welcome
  • Reports
    • State of the Bay
    • Bacterial Monitoring
    • EIA
  • Photo Gallery
  • Contributors
  • News
  • Who are we?
  • Contact

Western Cape government joins battle over mining

  • Home
  • Environmental Impact Assessments
  • Western Cape government joins battle over mining

Appeal filed against new coastal prospecting licence

  • UCT researchers have appealed the approval given to a local company by the Department of Mineral Resources and Energy for marine prospecting off the West Coast.
  • The researchers say the cumulative impact of numerous prospecting activities is not adequately considered when granting individual licenses.
  • The Western Cape Department of Environmental Affairs and Development Planning has also lodged an appeal.

Experts and environmentalists have raised concerns about whether the impact of numerous prospecting, mining and marine surveying operations on South Africa’s coastal waters is being given adequate weight when authorised individually.

In December the Department of Mineral Resources and Energy (DMRE) ) gave environmental authorisation for local company Belton Park Trading 127 to prospect for diamonds, gemstones, heavy minerals, industrial minerals, precious metals, and ferrous and base metals in three marine blocks just off the coast about 200km north of Cape Town.

Professor Merle Sowman of the Department of Environmental and Geographical Science at UCT has lodged an appeal, submitted jointly with research assistant Michael Lambrecht.

Sowman told GroundUp that ad hoc prospecting and mining applications as well as other development activities were being granted without a proper assessment of the cumulative impacts of these many operations on the coastal and marine environment.

In a 2014 strategy document, the Department of Forestry, Fisheries and Environment (DFFE) itself refers to assessing cumulative impacts to ensure that the “full range of consequences of actions is considered” in order to avoid “the tyranny of small decisions”.

Western Cape environment department not satisfied

Also appealing against the Belton authorisation is the Western Cape Department of Environmental Affairs and Development Planning, which raised the issue of the cumulative impact as well.

“The DMRE has approved multiple and sometimes overlapping survey, prospecting and mining activities on the offshore area along the West Coast without any attempt to assess the cumulative impacts,” the appeal states.

“The reports submitted by Belton Park as well as the Environmental Authorisation do not provide any indication that prospecting was considered in terms of cumulative impacts and if mining activities would be a desired outcome for the area.”

According to the province’s appeal, it is “imperative” that a strategic view be adopted, including the identification of sensitive areas where no prospecting or mining activities will be considered in line with a 2018 National Biodiversity Assessment.

The provincial department also raised concerns about whether local fishing communities had been properly involved in the approval process.

One of the questions in DFFE’s Appeal Questionnaire to appellants is: “Would you agree to the activity proceeding if your concerns can be addressed by rectifying the process or mitigating or eliminating the impacts of the activity?”

The province replied: “No. The proposed activities are incompatible with the conservation and ecotourism proposed uses of the areas and in conflict with local communities’ dependence on local ecosystem services.”

While not fundamentally opposed to any development activity on the site, the province believed that prospecting and mining activities were “inappropriate for the area”.

Sowman told GroundUp that her research group has been monitoring and recording the various prospecting, mining, oil and gas applications and their status over the past 18 months.

“I wonder whether DMRE and DFFE have this overview – how can they be making informed decisions when they don’t have full information?”

Department of Mineral Resources reasons

In its authorisation DMRE stated its Belton decision was based on information contained in an Environmental Impact Report and on proposed mitigation measures outlined in an Environmental Management Programme, both compiled for the company by SLR Consulting in association with three specialist consultants.

The department was satisfied that if mitigation measures were applied, the impact would be “low” to “very low”.

DMRE did not refer directly to the issue of cumulative impact in its authorisation. However, it stated it was satisfied that the Belton project would not be in conflict with the general objectives of Integrated Environmental Management.

Urgent interdict

On Thursday, the Cape High Court will hear an urgent interim interdict application to halt a seismic survey off the West Coast by Australian geodata supply company Searcher. The interdict application is part of a legal challenge to the May 2021 granting of a reconnaissance permit to Searcher by Petroleum Agency SA to conduct the survey.

The applicants include West Coast fishing communities and civic organisations.

A similar “Shell” seismic survey off the Transkei coast has also been temporarily blocked by the courts amid concern over the lack of scientific certainty about the impacts of prospecting and mining in the sea, and the inadequacy of legally required public participation processes.

 

Read the original article here at Groundup:   https://www.groundup.org.za/article/cumulative-impact-ignored-in-west-coast-mining-approvals/

 

Share this info on

Related documents

National Ports Authority
27/01/2022

NS Qingdao – Offloading of unstable chemicals in Port of Saldanha


Read more
06/12/2021

SAGITTA ENERGY PTY LTD FSRU & ARA ENERGY PTY LTD PIPELINE – Project Scope update


Read more
srk consulting
06/12/2021

Proposed Expansion of the Manganese Handling Facility at the Multi-Purpose Terminal, Port of Saldanha: Release of the Scoping Report for Public Review


Read more

Search for reports

✕

Report Archives

  • State of the Bay
  • Bacterial Pollution Monitoring
  • Environmental Impact Assessments
  • Aquaculture

Latest News

  • 2022-02-21 Bacterial Pollution Monitoring Results
    23/02/2022
  • Oil spill, Greater Saldanha Bay – 1 Feb 2022
    03/02/2022
  • Investigation of a green substance which was noticeable in the entire bay – Saldanha side
    17/12/2021
  • Marine Diversity
    WHY MARINE DIVERSITY MATTERS. A presentation by George & Margo Branch
    08/11/2021
  • Cormorants
     AVIAN FLU – Suspected outbreak of Avian Flu on the West Coast – Official SBM Press Release
    15/10/2021
  • SBWQFT Open Day Agenda 2021
    SBWQFT Open Day and State of the Bay Report: 22nd October 2021
    30/09/2021

Subscribe to receive emails

Receive an alert whenever new reports or other content is published. Opt out any time.

Email address


"Let us all, National, Provincial and Local Government with the Private Sector and Non-Governmental Organizations, as partners, take hands and make a difference in conserving our Saldanha Bay and Langebaan Lagoon for future generations whilst ensuring responsible development."

Councillor André Kruger
Portfolio Chairperson: Infrastructure and Planning Services, Saldanha Bay Municipality
Chairperson: Saldanha Bay Water Quality Trust

Who are we?

The Saldanha Bay Water Quality Forum Trust (SBWQFT) is a registered non-government organisation (NGO) that is voluntarily funded by large, medium and small industries operating within the area. This NGO creates a platform for discussions and mutual consent on the limitation and remediation of impacts on water quality and the marine ecosystem.

The SBWQFT acquires, receives and evaluates monitoring information effluents, marine water quality and ecosystem health. For over a decade the trust has collated scientific data, from the Saldanha Bay and Langebaan Lagoon ecosystems. The monitoring includes avifauna, many forms of marine life and sediment sampling at various points within this unique ecosystem.

Read more about our vision and goals here.



Contact us

Phone: 022 714-3367
Cell: 082 376-8529
Email: manager@sbwqft.org.za
sacoronavirus.co.za

Send an Email to SBWQFT


0 / 180
0 / 180
© 2018-2022 All Rights Reserved SBWQFT Saldanha Bay Water Quality Forum Trust, P.O. Box 446, Langebaan 7357, Western Cape, South Africa
Photography credits: Anchor Environmental Consultants, Biccard A, Griffiths CL, Trefson J, Turpie J, Clark B, Liebau V, Gittenberger A. | Privacy Policy and Website Terms of Use
Website designed and maintained by 247highway.com Design & Development

Click here for Details and Bookings - places are limited!